What if Everything You Know About Social Media Marketing is Wrong?

What if everything you “know” about social media marketing is wrong? What would this mean to your upcoming and current social marketing programs? Better yet, what might it mean to your job?

If you are employed in social media marketing, it is time for a healthy dose of reality followed by some serious soul searching and career planning. Some of you are lucky enough to work in the rare companies that create advocates with great products, service and mission and thus are equipped to leverage social media for marketing gain; most work at companies that have inflated their opportunities in the medium and are floundering with their social media marketing and content strategies.
Here’s the way a large number of social media professionals today go about justifying their programs, along with some recent data that may (and should) scare the hell out of you if you work in social media marketing:

  • Consumers welcome brands’ social media marketing. Untrue: A recent study by Kentico found that 68% of US consumers “mostly” or “always” ignore brand posts on every social network. A recent study of US college students by Concentric found that “nearly half stated they didn’t believe brands should be on social media or they didn’t personally follow brands” and “nearly 70% report following three or fewer brand across all social media.” A 2013 YouGov survey found that “most social media users feel negatively towards marketing strategies by companies on social media sites, with 35% saying that they often hide companies’ updates if they update too often.” And a global research study commissioned by Pitney Bowes recently found that 83% of consumers have had a bad experience with social media marketing.
     
  • Consumers find trustworthy the information shared by brands in social media. Untrue: In 2013, an Adobe study found that just 2% of US consumers felt that company social media pages were best for credibility, a figure almost 90% lower than the credibility of company websites or traditional advertising. Forrester’s recent data demonstrates that just 15% of US consumers trust the social media posts of brands, half the rate at which consumers trust information on company websites. Likewise, Nielsen recently found that ads on social networks were among the least trusted form of advertising, significantly lower than trust in ads viewed in traditional media.
  • Consumers who follow brands are interested prospects, making social an acquisition channel for brands. Untrue: The 2013 Adobe study found that more than half of consumers indicate they like brands because they already purchase from them while just than one in six US consumers indicate they like brands on Facebook because they aspire to buy from those brands. A 2013 YouGov study of UK consumers found that “the followers / likers of companies are most likely to be current customers (33%) whose primary motivation is a desire to get something in return (34%).” Digital consultancy L2 studied nearly 250 prestige brands and found that over four years, less than 0.25% of new customers had been acquired through Facebook and less than .01% from Twitter; this compares to almost 10% for paid search and 7% for email marketing. Moreover, L2 found that “customers acquired via social channels register lower lifetime value than customers acquired via search.”
      
  • Every fan and follower has value, because they reflect brand affinity and are a leading indicator of future success.  Untrue: There is no social media sacred cow more hallowed than this, yet this belief remains largely unstudied. I’ve tackled the issue twice. In 2012, I evaluated the 40 companies with the greatest Facebook fan counts that were both tracked by the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) and publicly traded. I found a modest negative correlation (-0.3) between Facebook fans and customer satisfaction and no correlation (-0.1) between Facebook fans and stock performance. I repeated a similar evaluation last month, studying the stock performance of the companies with the top 50 brand accounts on Twitter; I found the average performance of these companies was no better than the NASDAQ index and their median performance was significantly below the NASDAQ index.

    This data is supported by plenty of empirical evidence; for example, Lady Gaga’s ARTPOP saw disappointing sales despite the fact she heavily promoted the release via her Twitter profile, the fourth most popular profile on the service. Blackberry has collapsed, despite being one of the most popular brands on Twitter with 4 million followers. Dippin’ Dots declared bankruptcy mere days after collecting its 5 millionth Facebook fan. And Facebook likes were found to have little to no correlation to election results in the 2010 gubernatorial and House races. I continue to believe that fans earned authentically with the right brand purpose, products and services deliver value, but so many companies have “bought” meaningless fans with deals, discounts, sweepstakes and freebies that there is no correlation to be found between fans/followers and business outcomes.
      
  • Social Media content increases purchase intent. Untrue: While some social media content can deliver sales (see the mention of @DellOutlet in yesterday’s post), there is no evidence that the vast majority of brand content leads to any demonstrable increase in purchase behavior. The Kentico study found that 72% “never” or “hardly ever” purchase a product after hearing about it on a social network. A 2013 PwC study found that only 18% purchased a product as a result of information obtained through a social media site. This finding is similar to YouGov’s finding that just 13% of all social media users have bought something as a result of reading something on social media sites.

    None of these self-reported data points are very encouraging, but the measured data on social driving purchases is even worse. IBM tracked purchases across 800 retail sites and reported that social media drove just 1% of last year’s Black Friday online purchases. Meanwhile, Experian reports that social media sites, despite being the most popular sites on the Web, account for a mere 7.7% of all traffic to retail Websites (and Pinterest drives more traffic than either Facebook or Twitter).
       
  • Earned media is a growing way to reach consumers. Untrue: Facebook remains by leaps and bounds the place where consumers do most of their socializing (capturing 57% of all social visits according to Experian and consuming more than twice as much time as any other social site per Nielsen), but earned media on Facebook is dying. Social@Ogilvy has found that brands have suffered a 50% decline in reach in the past six months, and Facebook is warning marketers to expect further declines. Ogilvy predicts “the end of organic reach” is coming. Perhaps other social platforms will furnish better reach, but with the marketers pushing large quantities of brand content at consumers with little interest in seeing marketing in their social feeds, the recipe for success does not look encouraging. 

The time has come to start preparing for a marketing reassessment of the value of social media and earned media. While it was acceptable to experiment and make assumptions five years ago when social media was young, it is no longer tolerable (nor is it wise to your career) to believe and repeat the same tired, unfounded and incorrect notions.

Why do so many marketers believe things about social media marketing that are not supported by the data? In part, it is because an entire social media marketing industry has blossomed in the last seven years, and it is far more lucrative for this army of agencies, consultants, authors and speakers to sell marketers on earned media and content strategies than to acknowledge the woeful data or track record. As Upton Sinclair once said, “It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”

Also, marketers tend to make the mistake of thinking their own behaviors and that of consumers are alike, but they are not. Exact Target’s 2013 study “Marketers from Mars” found that marketers were 50% more likely than consumers to like a brand on Facebook, 400% more likely to follow brands on Twitter, 100% more likely to make a purchase as a result of seeing something on Facebook and 150% more likely to have completed a purchase as a result of a tweet. Marketers have done a better job of selling themselves on the value of social media marketing than they have of selling social media users on the value of their products and services.

Not only are marketers’ social behaviors vastly different than consumers’, they also have much greater confidence in content than do consumers. In the same study, marketers and consumers were asked where their favorite companies should invest more of their marketing time and resources to improve customer loyalty. Marketers were almost 80% more likely to cite content about products and 280% more likely to see content about related topics as a driver of consumer preference.

So, is it time for marketers to dismantle their social teams and abandon their social strategies? I’ve suggested as much in the past (and I’m hardly alone in this), but I’d like to close this blog post on a (slightly) more positive note. Rather than treating the title of this post–“What if Everything You Know About Social Media Marketing is Wrong?”– as if it is rhetorical, let’s instead answer the question.

The secret to successful social media marketing–and to protecting your job–is not to bury your head in the sand, ignore the data and continue building strategies based on deeply flawed assumptions. Instead, toss out all the faulty suppositions and start from scratch.  The key to success is not to assume that social media is a marketing channel but to assume it isn’t. Watch what happens if we take that same list of unsupported beliefs and turn them on their head:

  • Consumers DO NOT welcome brands’ social media marketing:  My brand must approach customers and prospects with great respect for their time and intelligence. We should stop posting silly “like this if you’re glad it’s Friday” and “Happy National Bubble Week” posts and instead provide content and functions that are worthy of people’s time and attention.
      
  • Consumers DO NOT find trustworthy the information shared by brands in social media.  We cannot take it as a matter of fact that anything our brand shares will be found credible. Instead of investing so much in content that our brand broadcasts in social media, we should strive to give our customers a greater voice–after all, people believe each other, not brands.
      
  • Consumers who follow brands ARE NOT interested prospects, and social is a WEAK acquisition channel for brands.  My fans and followers are not prospects but are, for the most part, existing customers. Our strategies should not focus on filling the top of the funnel but on loyalty, repurchase and advocacy.
      
  • Every fan and follower DOES NOT have value, and merely having fans IS NOT a leading indicator of future success.  Our brand should not try to collect the largest fan or follower base but should target a smaller set of the right people. Rather than attract people interested in contests and sweepstakes, we should strive to engage with customers interested in our company, its mission and its products and services. A smaller fan base of more valuable consumers trumps a large fan base of disinterested people who hide, ignore or do not see our posts.
      
  • Social Media content DOES NOT increase purchase intent. A funny viral video or clever Vine may accumulate lots of likes, but if it does not drive meaningful consideration or increased purchase intent, then it is worthless marketing. We must stop settling for content that we think keeps our brands “top of mind” and instead work harder to change minds! Even more vital is that we must reconsider our metrics–social media is a relationship medium, not a direct marketing channel. Unless we care to measure results in long-term metrics such as consideration, NPS, preference and the like, we have poor alignment between our marketing investments and objectives.
      
  • Earned media IS NOT a growing way to reach consumers. In the early days of the social era, we all had high hopes for earned media, but just as consumers avoid and ignore ads in other media, so too are they escaping the reach of organic marketing content in social media. Social media marketing requires an investment in paid media, and that means we have to get much better at knowing what content and interactions deliver value (and are worth putting money behind) and what do not. 

Tossing out all the baseless assumptions makes the job of social media marketing much more difficult, but it also forces us to build stronger, better strategies from the ground up. Too many social media marketers have fallen into ruts, and this has resulted in brands vomiting a useless flow of jokey, unmemorable, indistinct and unpersuasive posts and tweets. We have to stop posting content for content’s sake and start developing strategies designed to succeed. 

The investment in social media marketing has risen over the course of years, and so have the expectations. Either we change how we approach social media strategy, or CMOs will soon change the people responsible for those strategies. 

If you assume social media is a marketing channel full of interested consumers hungry for our content and ready to purchase, then any strategy makes sense (and will almost certainly fail.) This is the path to career pain.

Social media is not a marketing channel. If you can build social strategies that are designed to triumph despite that fact, then you are on your way to securing your career in social media marketing.

But take heed: The goal of this difficult process should not merely be to determine what your brand’s marketing strategies ought to be in social media but if it should even be trying. By starting with clearheaded and factual knowledge about the difficulties, the investments required and the long-term metrics that are best aligned to social media strategies, it may lead you to determine social media is best left to others in the organization.

Whatever your decision, just make sure it is one supported in facts and not naive myths and false promises. Your brand’s future and your career depends on it. 

69 thoughts on “What if Everything You Know About Social Media Marketing is Wrong?

  1. Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
    I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results.
    If you know of any please share. Many thanks! You
    can read similar art here: Escape rooms

  2. You actually make it appear so easy with your presentation however I to find this topic to be
    really something which I feel I might by no means understand.
    It kind of feels too complex and very huge for me. I’m looking
    ahead to your next submit, I will try to get the hang of
    it! Lista escape roomów

  3. Hey there, Natalie from Social Busy Bee, your guide in the exciting world of Instagram growth. I’ve stumbled upon something phenomenal for skyrocketing your Instagram popularity and I’m thrilled to share it with you!

    Social Growth Engine brings to you a groundbreaking service that takes your Instagram engagement to new heights. It’s a breeze:

    – Concentrate on producing captivating content.
    – Extremely budget-friendly at only $36/month.
    – Completely safe (no password needed), exceptionally effective, and the ideal Instagram companion.

    I’ve witnessed extraordinary results firsthand, and I’m certain you will too! Elevate your Instagram presence right now: http://get.socialbuzzzy.com/instagram_booster

    To your success,
    Your ally Natalie”

  4. Everything published made a bunch of sense. But,
    what about this? suppose you added a little information? I mean, I don’t want to tell you
    how to run your blog, but what if you added a post title to possibly get a person’s attention? I mean What if Everything You Know About
    Social Media Marketing is Wrong? is a little boring.
    You should look at Yahoo’s front page and see how they
    create article headlines to grab viewers to open the links.
    You might add a related video or a pic or two to grab people
    excited about everything’ve written. In my opinion, it could bring your website a little livelier.

  5. Can I simply just say what a relief to discover someone that truly knows what they’re talking about online.
    You actually know how to bring an issue to light and make it important.
    More and more people have to look at this and understand this side of your story.
    It’s surprising you’re not more popular because you definitely have the gift.

  6. Bienvenue sur notre forum dédié à l’IPTV en Suisse ! Ce sujet est destiné à tous ceux qui souhaitent partager et échanger des informations sur l’utilisation de l’IPTV en Suisse. Que vous soyez un débutant cherchant à comprendre les bases ou un utilisateur expérimenté avec des conseils à partager, ce topic est pour vous !

    Ce que vous trouverez ici :

    Introduction à l’IPTV : Qu’est-ce que l’IPTV et comment ça fonctionne en Suisse ?
    Fournisseurs d’IPTV en Suisse : Recommandations et retours d’expérience sur les différents fournisseurs disponibles.
    Installation et Configuration : Guides détaillés pour installer et configurer votre service IPTV.
    Problèmes Courants : Solutions aux problèmes fréquents rencontrés par les utilisateurs d’IPTV.
    Légalité et Réglementation : Discussion sur les aspects légaux de l’utilisation de l’IPTV en Suisse.
    Astuces et Trucs : Partage de conseils pour améliorer votre expérience IPTV.
    Offres et Promos : Les meilleures offres et promotions du moment.
    Pour plus d’informations et de ressources, consultez notre site partenaire : [url=https://iptv.museespeleo.ch/]iptv smarters pro[/url]

  7. Vivez la TV suisse comme jamais auparavant possible avec notre solution IPTV de excellente qualité !
    Bénéficiez d’un accès sans limites aux meilleures chaînes suisses comme la RTS, SRF, la RSI et bien d’autres. Notre service offre :

    Plus de centaines de chaînes suisses et mondiales en qualité HD
    Un catalogue VOD riche en films et émissions
    La option de revoir vos émissions préférées
    Une interface intuitive qui marche avec divers dispositifs
    Un support client dynamique basé en Suisse
    Que vous soyez enthousiaste de sport, de journaux télévisés ou de divertissement, notre IPTV
    [url=http://nutris.net/members/regretoption8/activity/1486568/]Nutris Activity[/url] s’adapte à vos envies. Testez gratuitement pendant 24 heures et découvrez une nouvelle façon de regarder la télé !

  8. Do you recall those moments once you caught sight of your friend’s mom and had been struck by her elegance? The term MILF involves brain, describing mature, alluring women who exude confidence and sensuality. Possibly the idea of engaging in intimacy with them seemed too daunting at the time. These women have a very certain allure which can be intimidating, because they know exactly what they desire and how to achieve it. It’s understandable in the event that you felt you couldn’t measure up to their level of experience and passion. However, you might have missed out on an unbelievable opportunity, as cougars are old women who are drawn to the vigor of young men. Despite being over thirty-five, their ardor and craving for excitement knows no bounds. Constantly in search of fresh encounters, they may have moved on before you even had a chance to consider approaching them. But fear not really, if you have ever fantasized about the bare beauty of an older woman’s form, our collection offers everything you could desire. You will be enraptured before you even realize it.

  9. Explorez les programmes suisses comme jamais expérimentée avec notre solution IPTV de excellente qualité !
    Obtenez un accès illimité aux meilleures chaînes suisses comme RTS (Radio Télévision Suisse), SRF (Schweizer Radio und Fernsehen), la RSI et bien d’autres. Notre plateforme offre :

    Plus de 100 chaînes locales et internationales en haute définition
    Un choix VOD riche en contenu vidéo
    La faculté de voir vos shows préférés en replay
    Une interface facile d’utilisation qui marche avec divers dispositifs
    Un assistance client rapide basé en Suisse
    Que vous soyez enthousiaste de sport, d’actualités ou de loisirs, notre solution IPTV
    [url=https://contestalert.in/members/personhoe60/activity/1376707/]Contest Alert – Activité sur l’IPTV[/url]
    s’adapte à vos besoins. Essayez sans frais pendant 24 heures et découvrez une façon innovante de voir la télévision !

  10. Предлагаю компанию gazon-msk, их специализация это газоны в рулонах – они профи.

  11. Feel the captivating allure of those stunning images showcasing powerful naked amateur mature pix enjoying their curves and even confidence in a collection exuding class and sexiness. Through a fiery redhead radiating natural beauty in order to a seductive girl enticing her gardener, each photograph tells a tale associated with mature erotica at its finest. Experience these mature women fearlessly owning their sensuality while watching contact lens, drawing you inside with their closeness and leaving an individual yearning for even more. Delve into some sort of realm of seduction and enchantment as they beauties display self-assuredness in lingerie, baring their sensual factors and relishing within private moments. Attempt a journey throughout the realm of nude women, from a new breathtaking blonde about the beach to the intimate regarding MILFs beckoning one to explore their sensuality through alluring nighties.

  12. Good post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites I stumbleupon everyday. It’s always exciting to read articles from other writers and practice something from their websites.

  13. You are so interesting! I do not believe I’ve read through something like this before. So good to find another person with some original thoughts on this subject matter. Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This site is something that’s needed on the web, someone with a little originality.

  14. בדירות הדיסקרטיות כאשר הם חוגגים אירועים מיוחדים. אבל לא צריך לחכות לאירוע מיוחד. דירות דיסקרטיות בחיפה הן מקום להגשים בו את כל בדירות הדיסקרטיות כאשר הם חוגגים אירועים מיוחדים. אבל לא צריך לחכות לאירוע מיוחד. דירות דיסקרטיות בחיפה הן מקום להגשים בו את כל look at here now

  15. מזה. דירות דיסקרטיות בחיפה לבילוי 24 שעות ביממה דירות דיסקרטיות בחיפה היא המקום שאליו כולם שואפים להגיע. והאמת שאין שום דבר בחיפה הן מקום שבו אפשר למצוא יפיפיות אמיתיות, בעלות גוף סקסי ומחוטב. הן מגיעות לכאן מכל העולם, והן שמחות להכיר גברים ישראלים read full article

  16. כולו רגעים נעימים שיעשו לך טוב. רגעים של תשוקה גדולה, עיסוי אירוטי והרבה מאוד אינטימיות. כאשר מדברים על נערות ליווי בחיפה, שהגבר אוהב. אז אם בא לך להתמסר לעולמות העונג האין סופי, זה בדיוק מה שאתה צריך. הנערות יטפלו בך, ויגרמו לך לשכוח מכל הדאגות. נערות ליווי ברמת גן

  17. ליווי ממדינות שונות. לכל אחת מראה שונה וייחודי, ולכל אחת גישה משלה לצורך פינוק הגבר. אבל כולן מקפידות על רמה גבוהה של שירות, הן וכאשר יש דירות דיסקרטיות בבאר שבע, תוכל לעשות זאת בקלי קלות. הדירות הדיסקרטיות הן הפתרון המתאים עבור כל הגברים. לפעמים זהו try this out

  18. מהאטרקציות של העיר, אטרקציה הפונה גם אל תושבי העיר, וגם אל הגברים המגיעים לכאן ממקומות אחרים ורוצים ליהנות מכל מה שיש לעיר חיפה להזמין את הנערות לביתם או לבית המלון ולשמור על פרטיות מלאה. להגשים פנטזיות עם נערות ליווי בתל אביב לכל גבר יש את הפנטזיות informative post

  19. אחרת. אבל לכולן משותף הגוף המושלם. גוף שעושה לך חשק רק לגעת ולקבל ממנו עוד ועוד. אם זה הישבן העסיסי החזה השופע או שניהם ביחד – וגברים נשואים. ועל מנת להעניק שירות לקהל אקסקלוסיבי זה, הן מקפידות על דיסקרטיות ופרטיות של לקוחותיהם. הן מגיעות ונותנות שירות check it out

  20. גדול ועור רך ונעים כפי שאתה אוהב. ואלו הם הכלים באמצעותם נערות הליווי מפנקות את הגברים וגורמות לגבר להרגיש טוב. בילוי דיסקרטי משתמשים על מנת לתאר את החוויה. אך נראה כי שום מילה לא יכולה לתאר את החוויה בצורה מדויקת. בשביל להבין צריך לנסות. ואם אתה רוצה learn the facts here now

  21. יכולים להיות חיילים, סטודנטים, גרושים או בקיצור כל גבר ממוצע שרוצה לבלות. זהו פתרון המשלב גם נערה יפה שמפנקת אותך, וגם סביבת תהיה בטוח שאתה הולך ליהנות. יש הרבה סיבות מדוע לבקר דירות דיסקרטיות בחיפה, ולא צריך תכניות מיוחדות. זהו מסוג הבילויים שניתן דירה דיסקרטי

  22. לחוץ מכל מה שקורה מסביב – יש לנו את התשובה בשבילך. כל מה שאתה צריך לעשות זה פשוט להזמין נערות ליווי בתל אביב ולהתחיל לבלות. הן הגבר הנשוי שבא לו לגוון ולבלות עם בחורה צעירה, אבל אין לו את ההזדמנות לעשות זאת בגלל המשפחה שבבית. ולפעמים אלו הם חיילים צעירים מכוני סקס וכל הפינוקים למתעניינים

  23. נערות סקסיות וחרמניות. דירות דיסקרטיות בתל אביב זו חוויה שקשה לתאר במילים כאשר מנסים לתאר את החוויה של דירות דיסקרטיות בתל בחיפה – האטרקציה של העיר יש הרבה דברים טובים בחיפה, אבל ישנה אטרקציה אחת שהיא מיועדת רק לגברים. אנו מדברים על נערות ליווי מסאז אירוטי בחיפה

  24. מהאטרקציות של העיר, אטרקציה הפונה גם אל תושבי העיר, וגם אל הגברים המגיעים לכאן ממקומות אחרים ורוצים ליהנות מכל מה שיש לעיר חיפה מהחיים הוא צריך לקחת אחריות על החיים שלו ולבחור את הבילויים שעושים לו טוב. לא צריך לדפוק חשבון כאשר מדובר במימוש הגבריות שלך. read contentsays:

  25. זורמות עם הגבר. אז מה התכניות שלך להערב? להיות לבד או לעשות משהו טוב למען עצמך? נראה לנו שאתה יודע את התשובה! הזמן נערה ותגשים זאת בכל יום ובכל שעה, והן רק מחכות שגם אתה תבוא לבלות איתן. דירות דיסקרטיות בחיפה לחוויה משחררת ישנם גברים המגיעים לבלות סקס בדרום תל אביב

  26. לחוץ מכל מה שקורה מסביב – יש לנו את התשובה בשבילך. כל מה שאתה צריך לעשות זה פשוט להזמין נערות ליווי בתל אביב ולהתחיל לבלות. הן שלו, את הפנטזיות שבוערות בתוכו ואותן הוא רוצה להגשים. כל גבר יכול להגשים את הפנטזיות וזה מה שהוא צריך לעשות בשביל לחיות חיים go to page

  27. Чудо Гриб препарат от паразитов https://chydogrib.ru и ВПЧ. Купите средство по минимальной цене, изучите отзывы и инструкцию по применению.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Powered by Blogger.