Monday, April 25, 2016

The Broken Customer Experience of Media and Publishing

photo credit: Words via photopin (license)
Publishers have traditionally focused on the quality of their content rather than their customer experience, but trends in technology and consumer behavior are changing that. Two recent occurrences made me think of how vital customer experience is to the future of individual companies in this category and the concept of an independent and trusted news media.

The first of these occurrences was reading earlier this year about one newspaper's problems with delivery as they switched distributors. My friend Josh Bernoff wrote about the troubles from both the professional and personal perspectives (since he was not getting his newspaper as expected). Even in this digital age, physical distribution of the newspaper matters, because media organizations, like most companies, must serve their existing customers while finding ways to attract new ones with evolving digital models. And it matters in this particular industry because digital ad revenues have not come close to making up for the 65% loss in print ad revenues newspapers have suffered in the past decade.

Publishers' desire to increase ad revenue can come into sharp conflict with users' expectations, which brings me to my second recent occurrence that brought the customer experience of media to mind. Last week I visited a tech site to read an article, and I honestly felt as if I was in a digital jungle hacking through the spam undergrowth to get to my destination. My experience on this site followed this tortuous path:
  • Close a pop-up ad in a new window.
  • Close an overlay ad that obscured the content.
  • Start reading--momentarily--before a video push-down ad appeared at the top of the page, forcing my content off the bottom.
  • Scroll down to continue reading for fifteen seconds before the push-down ad (which was playing unseen above the top of my window) disappeared, causing the content to scroll once again off the page.
  • Scroll up to continue reading.
  • At this point, the site launched yet another overlay. This one asked me to subscribe to the mailing list. To make matters worse, closing the overlay required me to click a statement along the lines of "No, I don't care about the upcoming trends in tech." Does this publisher think its users are so simpleminded they can be manipulated into registering because of an aversion to clicking that phrase?

I left the site without reading the article. After 30 seconds, I'd read just two paragraphs and was forced to take five separate actions because ads either blocked the content or chased it off my screen. I will not return to this site. In fact, I hope no one does.

Desperate times may call for desperate measures for publishers, but the customer is still in charge. To read more about how consumers are reacting, how publishers are responding, why trust in the news media is at crisis levels and how customer experience is a powerful tool for publishers, please continue reading on the Gartner blog.

1 comment:

Ken Hittel said...

Augie, pls. name -- & shame -- the site. It deserves it.